| Sector | Ticker / Name | Price | DEA Score | ROE (%) | NPM (%) | P/E | Leverage (%) | Status |
|---|
| Rank | Sector | Ticker | Company Name | DEA Score | P/E (Input) | Lev % (Input) | P/B (Input) | EPS (Output) | NPM % (Output) | ROE % (Output) | Selection |
|---|
🏆 Total Return Outperformance:
The CRS model achieved +366.36% total cumulative return across the 9 years compared to +176.08% for the KSE Weighted Index (more than 2x).
🛡️ 2008 Financial Crisis Protection:
During 2008 crash, the KSE market plunged -43.06%, whereas the DEA CRS Portfolio lost only -29.34% (sparing over 30% of market loss).
📈 Bank Rate Comparison:
The portfolio beat Average Interest Rates (AIR = 33.44% total) in 6 out of 9 years with a p-value of statistical significance.
| Year | DEA CRS Model (%) | DEA VRS Model (%) | KSE Weighted Index (%) | Bank Interest Rate (%) | Outperformance vs Index |
|---|
Theoretical Framework & Research Design
From the MBA thesis: "Stock Selection Using Data Envelopment Analysis for Constructing Investment Portfolios" by Ahmed El Atriby (Maastricht School of Management).
1. Multi-Criteria Inputs & Outputs
The model eliminates the bias of relying solely on single financial ratios by utilizing non-parametric linear programming envelopment frontiers:
• P/E Ratio (Price to Earnings) - measures how expensive the stock is
• Leverage % (Debt to Equity) - indicator for bankruptcy and distress risk
• P/B Ratio (Price to Book) - measures overvaluation vs book assets
Outputs (Profitability & Returns to maximize):
• EPS (Earnings Per Share) - absolute profit generation capability
• Net Profit Margin % (NPM) - cost control and operational efficacy
• ROE % (Return on Equity) - efficiency in deploying shareholder capital
2. Output-Oriented Super Efficiency Formulation
subject to:
∑ (λ_j * x_ij) ≤ x_ik (for all inputs i, j ≠ k)
∑ (λ_j * y_rj) ≥ φ * y_rk (for all outputs r, j ≠ k)
λ_j ≥ 0 (CRS) or ∑ λ_j = 1 (VRS)
Extracted Visual Figures from Thesis
Diagrams, efficiency frontiers, and conceptual model charts extracted directly from the original thesis document: